Monday Motivation
“I attribute this to my success. I never gave or took any excuse.” –Florence Nightingale
Mandatory Helmet Laws and Cycling Safety
There has been a lot of discussion about whether the mandatory helmet laws are a good idea or not. Recently it resurfaced in the Australian Senate. (We’re talking traditional helmets here, not this kind.)
As I recall there are at least three main issues: 1) the effectiveness of helmets, 2) whether they help or hinder safety on the road, 3) whether helmet laws deter cycling in general.
On the effectiveness of helmets, I’ve had at least two concussions… er, that I can remember. The most serious one, referred to as “the alleged accident” at Velo Logic HQ, where I was unconscious and hospitalized, happened taking a gentle corner at 16-18 mph (according to a friend behind me).
Ever since then I’ve had doubts about the efficacy of helmet, though I still wear one. (On helmet ineffectiveness see Robinson Dorothy, 2006. Do enforced bicycle helmet laws improve public health?. BMJ 2006;332:722-725.)
Regarding helmets effect on the road, research has shown that drivers give cyclists without helmets significantly more room when passing. (Ian Walker found that wearing a helmet led to a 23% increase in cars inside the 3 ft danger zone, Accident Analysis & Prevention, March 2007.)
In my opinion the issue is easily resolved. As the Aussies say, it’s bloody simple mate, leave it up to the cyclists, let each person decide whether to wear a helmet or not. We’re big boys and girls, we can make up our own minds and accept the consequences.
This is not a trivial issue, which is precisely why people should be able to decide for themselves, not forced to conform to what politicians and bureaucrats decide is best.
What say ye?
Australian Senate Inquiry Hears from Doctors and Academics
Cycling Demonstration for Fallen Cyclist Disrupted by Bus Collision
In Helsinki a group of 850 cyclists riding in honor of a cyclist killed in a collision with a car last week, were inadvertently part of a demonstration of just how dangerous cycling can be, when a bus ran into the group. Thankfully no one was seriously injured, but fisticuffs ensued between a cyclist and the bus driver.
Bus Collides with Cycling Safety Demonstrators
—–
Let’s make it a great week, no excuses.
